Kalshi Loses Maryland Appeal as Judges Split on Legal Reasoning

The Fourth Circuit’s 59-page ruling contains a one-sentence judgment affirming the lower court, followed by three separate judicial opinions.
One detail in the document concerns Kalshi’s own advertising. Judge Roger Gregory cited the platform’s description of itself as the "first app for legal sports betting in all 50 states."
One Result, Two Legal Arguments
Gregory left open whether Kalshi’s sports contracts qualify as swaps under federal commodities law. He found that even if they do, the Commodity Exchange Act does not clearly prevent Maryland from enforcing its gambling rules.
Judge Stephanie Thacker agreed with the result but took a different approach. She found that the contracts are not swaps because payments depend on the outcome of a sporting event rather than whether the event occurs.
Judge DeAndrea Benjamin dissented. She considered the contracts swaps and argued that federal oversight should take precedence over Maryland’s gambling laws.
A Dispute Dating Back to April 2025
Maryland sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter on April 7, 2025. That gave the company 15 days to stop offering unlicensed sports wagering in the state.
Kalshi filed suit on April 21. A federal district judge refused to block Maryland’s enforcement in August 2025, leading to this week’s appeal.
Maryland’s licensing rules also cover advertising, including restrictions on marketing directed at people prohibited from wagering.
Four Appeals Courts, Only One Kalshi Win
The Third Circuit backed Kalshi in New Jersey in April. Nevada’s Ninth Circuit ruled against the company in August.
September brought another setback when the Sixth Circuit rejected Kalshi’s requests for protection in Ohio and Tennessee, as 15M reported at the time. Maryland changes that appellate record from 2-1 to 3-1 against Kalshi.
The November 17 judgment leaves Kalshi without the preliminary injunction it sought in Maryland. It does not decide the company’s final liability under state gambling law.
Have you enjoyed the news?