Skip to content
Become a Partner

43 State AGs Demand Withdrawal of CFTC Sports Contract Rule

43 State AGs Demand Withdrawal of CFTC Sports Contract Rule
Attorneys general from 43 US states and Washington, DC, called on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to withdraw its proposed rule on sports prediction markets on November 18. The coalition argues that the agency lacks both the legal authority and the required number of commissioners to adopt it.

The coalition’s November 18 filing challenges the classification of sports event contracts as financial swaps under federal commodities law. Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson, who co-led the effort, argued that the CFTC cannot expand its authority over sports betting simply by redefining those contracts, as NewsForce247 reported.

States Challenge the Definition and the Commission’s Authority

The coalition wants the CFTC to abandon its attempt to bring sports contracts explicitly within the federal swap definition. It argues that sporting outcomes do not satisfy the law’s requirement for a connection to potential financial, economic or commercial consequences.

The attorneys general also raise a procedural objection. They argue that the commission lacks the quorum required to adopt the rule while Chairman Michael Selig remains its only serving member.

The coalition warns that the proposal could allow licensed sportsbooks to move their betting products onto federally regulated exchanges. Such a shift could leave state requirements on licensing, age verification and responsible gambling protections outside the applicable regulatory framework.


CFTC’s Own Figures Show the Scale of the Dispute

The CFTC’s October 19 proposal contains two details relevant to the states’ objections.

  • $1.2 billion in estimated average monthly trading volume came from sports event contracts in August 2026.
  • $1.5 billion was the corresponding figure for all reported event contracts.

Sports therefore represented approximately 80% of reported event-contract trading volume, based on a 15M calculation using the regulator’s estimates. These figures concern trading activity, not sportsbook revenue.

The CFTC’s cost analysis also acknowledges that states might lose licensing fees and other revenue if businesses reorganize as federally regulated contract markets.


Maryland Ruling Adds Another Legal Complication

The coalition cites appellate decisions in the Sixth and Ninth Circuits that rejected federal jurisdiction arguments advanced by prediction market operators. Maryland’s November 17 decision adds a different problem. As 15M reported, the Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 against Kalshi, but the two judges in the majority did not agree on whether its sports contracts qualify as swaps.

One judge rejected that classification. The other found that Maryland could enforce its gambling laws even if the contracts were swaps. The dissenting judge supported federal jurisdiction.

The coalition’s filing arrived on the November 18 deadline for comments on the proposed rule, listed under RIN 3038-AF82.


What Happens Next

For US-facing betting operators and affiliates, the submission creates no immediate change to licensing or advertising requirements. The CFTC must still decide whether to finalize, revise or withdraw the proposal, while the courts continue examining the boundary between federal derivatives regulation and state gambling laws.

Author of the news

Content writer

Olga is an iGaming editor and writer with hands-on experience in the industry since 2023. She covers industry news, operator updates, product launches, and key developments across the global gambling market.

Author Profile

Have you enjoyed the news?