Malta Bill 55 Escapes EU Court Ruling in Austrian €5,000 Advice Case

The judgment in Case C-683/24 arose from a claim against a legal adviser, not a casino. The Austrian proceedings concerned a legal opinion delivered in 2023, shortly after Malta changed its gambling legislation.
How a €5,000 Opinion Reached Luxembourg
Spielerschutz Sigma finances lawsuits by Austrian players seeking refunds from Malta-licensed gambling operators. It had won judgments in Austria and wanted to enforce them in Malta.
In June 2023, Malta introduced Article 56A of its Gaming Act, commonly called Bill 55. The amendment restricts recognition and enforcement of certain foreign judgments against licensed operators.
Spielerschutz Sigma asked a legal adviser whether the measure complied with EU law. The opinion arrived on July 5, 2023. It said Article 56A was plainly incompatible with EU rules and would not be applied by Maltese courts.
Fourteen days later, a Maltese court relied on that provision to refuse enforcement of an Austrian judgment. Spielerschutz Sigma learned of the refusal on August 1.
The company subsequently sued its adviser in Vienna, demanding its €5,000 fee back and compensation for losses connected with the intervening period.
Malta’s Legal Protection Remains Untested
The EU judges refused to answer Vienna’s questions. They said the adviser’s liability had to be assessed against the law and information available when the opinion was written. A ruling delivered in 2026 would not determine whether that advice was professionally defensible in July 2023.
Malta had also requested the reopening of proceedings in May, but the Court rejected the application.
Advocate General Nicholas Emiliou had recommended the same procedural outcome in April. He nevertheless considered Article 56A incompatible with EU enforcement rules. The judges did not adopt that assessment.
The European Commission’s infringement proceedings, opened in June 2025, remain a separate challenge to Malta’s legislation. Thursday’s judgment settles neither that dispute nor the legality of Bill 55.
Have you enjoyed the news?